Pages

Thursday, December 15, 2011

The Duggars, our fading morals and a giant rant.

What has happened to our society?  

When did it become tolerable - no, acceptable - no, the mainstream view, to bash a family going through something as horrendous as losing a baby at almost 20 weeks?

I'll admit that I used to think the Duggars were nuts.  This was long before I was saved and long before I got sucked into an episode.  All I heard were the tabloid headlines and other people's summaries of the show.  And, yeah, 18 kids?  19?  20?  Crazy.  For ME.  But why in the world does that matter?  Because I've chosen to have three children, that makes me superior to them?  No, it just makes me a different person with different desires.

But then I was saved.  And now I wrestle with the idea of birth control all the time.  I pray about it.  I talk to other Christians.  But ultimately, I've made the decision to take my procreation into my own hands and decide that I don't want anymore children after this third one.  Because I'm too weak to trust God's plan.  I'm too weak to think that He could know better than me.  

So I have to admire the Duggars.  And respect them.  They can do something I'm not capable of.  They have the ultimate faith.

But because they're famous, society says that makes them fair game for hate and ignorance and bashing.  Upon news of their latest pregnancy, a lot of people had a lot of things to say.  At first, I didn't have a clue what to think.  Then I realized it wasn't really my business.  And then, ultimately, I realized that I admired their faith.  And I admire the way they raise their children and I admire that they are able to support them all.  So what if that's via a TV show on TLC?  They also shop only second hand and make a MUCH greater effort to leave a small carbon footprint than I ever have.

Really, whose business is it?  Theirs and God.  That's what I think.  

People's opinions on the matter frustrated me a little bit, but I certainly understood as I walked in those same shoes just a few years ago.  I was right there, judging them along with everyone else.

But then, when they recently announced their loss and the truly EVIL comments started to surface, I wanted to throw up.  I also might have wanted to punch a few people in the face because I'm not the perfect Christian, but I could at least show a little restraint.  

The comments made that the Duggars deserved this tragedy, and that it's God's way of telling them to stop, were some of the lowest blows I've ever seen Americans make toward other fellow Americans.  To take someone's horrendous tragedy (this wasn't an early miscarriage, this was as close to stillbirth as you can get without being called a stillbirth) and use it to gloat or make yourself feel better is so sad there are just no words.  

When TMZ shamefully leaked pictures of the Duggars baby that were passed out at the memorial service, the reaction was how dare the Duggars!  

How dare the Duggars?  How about how dare TMZ?  How dare whoever shared this with TMZ?  That someone could blame a family who has lost a baby for sharing a picture of their baby's hands and feet with their fellow loved ones is just beyond me.  Some of the comments that I saw on the STFU, Parents FB page post (who I will never read or support again):

Original post from STFU, Parents:


Comments:


I would have to argue that it's not a family who has lost a baby and wants to remember and share that baby, to know that baby had a purpose in the world who is sick.  But, psh, what do I know?



Yeah, how dare the Duggars want to remember their lost baby girl and share her with their loved ones!  Gah!  Sick!  Tasteless!  Totally trivializes their loss!


Oh, right!  Let's get the government involved and forcefully remove her uterus!  What a great idea!  She's had 19 kids and 2 miscarriages.  I'd say the odds are pretty in their favor considering 1 in 4 pregnancies ends in miscarriage.  And furthermore, the idea that having a miscarriage and/or a stillborn baby means you shouldn't be allowed to have more children makes no sense.  We don't tell women in this country who can't get pregnant on their own that this means God is trying to tell them not to have children.  No, we assist them with medical miracles, and I think it's wonderful.  We don't tell women who've had four miscarriages in a row that they would be irresponsible to keep trying.  No, we hug them and wipe their tears away and encourage them and remind them that God is in control, and not one of those miscarried babies didn't have a purpose.  God has a purpose for ALL life he creates, miscarried, stillborn or otherwise.

Just because someone's belief system is different, if it does not actively affect YOU (i.e., were they taking government assistance, you might be able to have a say in her procreation), I just don't believe people have the right to voice such nastiness in the direction of a family who is just trying to put their faith in God while responsibly caring for their children and this earth.

The worst ones, the ones that made me stop and actually cry, were these:




Though I found it tasteless for STFU, Parents, to have started a thread picking on this family, what I found much more tasteless was the writer's shock when people came to the defense of the Duggars, and then the anger that followed.  I only hope that the writer of STFU, Parents, and all the nasty commenters never have to experience a tragedy like the Duggars.  Like it or not, we're all putting ourselves out there.  Everyone with a public facebook page, everyone with a blog, everyone with a TV show.  To say that I would deserve being made fun of while going through a tragedy because I put my life out there on my blog is a true testament to how far the morals in our society have sunk.  NO ONE deserves being viciously attacked during a period of extreme grief.  Not even a murderer.  The internet has allowed cruel people a stage to spread hate without suffering real life consequences, and it's time we demand that it stop.  


What she was really trying to say is: if I ever go through a tragedy, I'm fair game!  If I lose my baby, you have every right to violate my privacy and tell me I deserved it because I run this blog for profit!  I am ACTIVELY seeking attention!

The Duggars may profit from their TV show.  So?  The Duggars may have made themselves famous.  So?  As if that somehow negates their right to privacy, to respect in times of grief, to common courtesy that is afforded to anyone else who isn't famous.  

Whether you're a Christian or not, hate, in any form, is counterproductive and detrimental.  Even if you don't like someone, whether they're a blog writer or a facebook friend or a movie star, try to remember that we're all human and we all have feelings and saying such incredibly hurtful things to another has the potential to cut in deeper ways than you could ever imagine.  It has the potential to destroy another life.  DESTROY.  Let that sink in.

14 comments :

  1. I'm mad about this too. There is an organization of volunteer professional photographers called "Now I Lay Me Down To Sleep" that serves to take pictures of babies that have died for the family. For some families, these pictures are all they ever have of their child. Those people that are leaving those horrible comments have obviously never lost a baby. If they had, they'd understand.

    It wasn't in poor taste for the Duggars to take a picture of their baby and share it for the people they considered to be family and friends. It was a horrible breech of trust for whoever leaked the pictures to do something like that. How DARE that person make a profit off of someone's loss like that? It's sick.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chelsea! Something we agree on! HAHA, just teasing. But yes, the comments from "Christians" about poor Michelle's miscarriage really infuriated me. To say that "God was trying to tell her something" is really ridiculous, God is the creator of life, if He didnt want her to have more children, she wouldnt. I had read they found out the baby died at the U/S to learn the sex, so she had to have been at least 18 weeks along. :( So sad.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Michelle Duggar has truly changed and challenged my faith. Although I can't have an unlimited number of children, I have decided that as many as I can safely carry, I will. And I trust the God-given authority of my doctor. I had a miscarriage before my first, and before my latest pregnancy. It was heart-wrenching and heart-breaking. How people could say that God is telling them to stop, is ridiculous. Was I never supposed to have my two (almost three) special blessings? What if I had stopped? My sister has had 7 miscarraiges (at least). She is now blessed with a miracle baby that no doctor said she could ever have. God gives us these blessings, and Michelle is probably in better shape than I am to carry a child. She had to have emergency gall bladder surgery in the middle of her last pregnancy - that can happen in any pregnancy, first, last, young, old. That had nothing to do with her ability to carry a child. People only have hate because the Duggar's view of the world and their faith challenge them. And it's always easier to criticize them than to examine your own life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Re: putting a picture in the memorial leaflet. While I find it hard to look at the photo of a baby who has passed away, how is it any different than when we put a picture of my grandma in her memorial leaflet? Sure, she had nearly 90 years worth of photos to choose from, whereas this little baby didn't even have one day. So sad. I agree with you: not shame on the Duggars for using a photo. Shame on the rest of us for gawking at it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. wow this was very well written. I agree with you. Just horrendous :( I didnt' realize some of these cmoments. I felt sick to my stmoach reading these!! :( how awful. poor duggars. it is such a tradgedy :(

    ReplyDelete
  6. Find a better cause than the Duggars. Seriously.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Peggy. :)

    It's not a cause, just something that needed to be said.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I wasn't hiding my name, Sherlock. I just didn't have any of those ID's.

    Well, it's your right to say it. Since you came on our board to troll, I thought I'd return the favor.

    I've said it before and I'll say it again. The Duggar's have made their fortune promoting Michelle's womb. If she had 4 kids she wouldn't have a show. She keeps cranking 'em out, and the publicity is fine with them. There is a fipside to fame, and that's fame when you don't want it. Bed. Made. Lie. I don't wish harm on her fetuses but I dislike the media whoring. And I will comment on it. I will not go to a Duggar fansite and do it, though. That's just being an asshole.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Like I made pretty clear on the STFU, Parents page, Peggy, I found the post because I was a FAN who read that blog all the time. Not a troll.

    You have a right to your opinion, certainly, and I will allow you to share it on my blog, but you don't have a right to call me a troll or an asshole when you have your facts completely mixed up.

    But, let me point out that you did not go to a Duggar fansite to comment, but you did stalk my facebook page to find my blog and comment here. That's a little strange, no? You certainly were no reader of my blog before this evening.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you for posting this, Chelsea. I have been so sickened by all the hate being slung out there in regards to this family. It brought back the pain of my own miscarriage & made me ache for them in their loss. I cannot believe how we, as Christians & humans, can use someone's very personal tragedy & turn it into an opportunity for hate. The way I see it is we all make choices & we all have to live with them. We are all also entitled to our opinions..... the nice part is we are not forced to live our lives based on the opinions of others. You & I might feel offended by what people are saying about the Duggars & this tragedy but I am willing to bet they have taken this turn of events as a learning & growing opportunity..... another chance to grow in their faith. I only wish I was a strong. I want to scream the most awful things at the people perpetuating this stream of vileness. (sigh) God sure has his hands full with me!!!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I rarely comment but I've been reading your blog since Ben was born. I have to say, this is one of your best posts that I found myself agreeing with absolutely everything you said. I, like you, admire this family's faith and their ability to provide for these children. How many people do we know that can't provide for two or even one...but look at this family trusting the Lord and making it happen and all before a show even came along...while others stand on the outside casting their stones. My heart breaks for them. I stopped reading STFU Parents almost a year ago (not that I read it for amusement...I think I honestly went there to see if any of my statuses showed up.) It angers me that we think shaming others is acceptable.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've never been a Duggar fan for a myriad of reasons, but even I have to say this mocking of their tragedy is pretty sick. The term "miscarriage" is misleading. It sounds like she just got her period late. They actually delivered a stillborn *baby* and it's very sad.

    Obviously these comments are from the internet which brings out the worst in people. I'd love to see any one of these people come face to face with Mrs. Duggar and tell her what they wrote.

    Have some decency, people.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I have 5 boys. I lost our only baby girl at 21wks. I took pictures. I "shared" them in her memorial leaflet. My only regret about that is that I wish I'd taken more. You can't imagine the pain; I now know what drives people to drugs. I feel for Mrs. Duggar. The # in the "line-up" doesn't lessen the blow. Cyber-hugs... very well written.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This is truly well written Chelsea. It is so sick the way people are treating the Duggars. Mrs. Duggar is a grieving mother. No matter how many children you have, you love them all equally. Also, for the other comments posted...the Duggars live debt free and that was LONG before the show was even created. They own several commercial properties that they rent out....I'm sure they could live on that alone without the show! Second, they buy all second hand clothes and cook most food from scratch...they raise those kids better than a lot of families with only 2 kids in America could say. Plus, look at all the mission work they do to help others! Again, all that was done before the show even aired. I do not think the Duggars do things for fame, I believe they are trying to reach out to whoever possible to show them their love for God and how much he has blessed their own lives, in hopes that someone watching will also turn their own hearts to God. Anyway, I loved this blog post because no matter how many children you have, a loss is a loss. Mrs. Duggar is a grieving mother and that is the bottom line here.

    ReplyDelete